Organophile, MEMBER
Vuxen, India
0 poäng (VäTE)
September 3, 2008 21:49

Why can't humans digest cellulose?

Why can't humans digest cellulose? If genes which code for cellulases are inserted into the human genome, will we be able to eat grass? Couldn't that prevent food shortage?



TAGGAR:
inventorkid, MEMBER
16, United States
3 poäng (VäTE)


No mammal makes the necessary enzymes to break down cellulose. Those mammals that eat a lot of cellulose, like cows, need to keep symbiotic bacteria in their digestive tracks to help them digest the cellulose. If we could be somehow given the gene to make enzymes to digest cellulose, then we could get nutrition from eating grass.

 
   
stdClass Object
(
    [cid] => 2146
    [pid] => 0
    [nid] => 1260
    [subject] => Re:Why can\'t humans digest cellulose?
    [comment] => 

No mammal makes the necessary enzymes to break down cellulose. Those mammals that eat a lot of cellulose, like cows, need to keep symbiotic bacteria in their digestive tracks to help them digest the cellulose. If we could be somehow given the gene to make enzymes to digest cellulose, then we could get nutrition from eating grass.

[format] => 4 [timestamp] => 1220519837 [name] => inventorkid [mail] => [homepage] => [uid] => 438 [registered_name] => inventorkid [signature] => [signature_format] => 4 [picture] => [data] => a:13:{s:17:"profile_firstname";s:3:"Max";s:16:"profile_lastname";s:7:"Wallack";s:14:"profile_gender";s:3:"Boy";s:12:"profile_city";s:6:"Natick";s:16:"profile_address1";s:4:"NULL";s:16:"profile_address2";s:4:"NULL";s:7:"contact";s:1:"0";s:15:"profile_country";s:0:"";s:13:"profile_title";s:0:"";s:19:"profile_affiliation";s:0:"";s:21:"profile_pro_interests";s:0:"";s:17:"profile_languages";s:0:"";s:16:"profile_comments";s:0:"";} [thread] => 00/ [status] => 0 [profile_firstname] => Max [profile_lastname] => Wallack [profile_gender] => Boy [profile_city] => Natick [profile_address1] => NULL [profile_address2] => NULL [contact] => 0 [profile_country] => [profile_title] => [profile_affiliation] => [profile_pro_interests] => [profile_languages] => [profile_comments] => [depth] => 0 [new] => 0 )
John, MENTOR
Vuxen, Greece
6 poäng (VäTE)


I believe that humans could digest cellulose, if they're given the enzyme that digests cellulose. Maybe we need to modify the enzymes those bacteria make.

For instance people that suffer from diabetes, do not suffer now, without needing to insert genes into their genome ;)

 
   
stdClass Object
(
    [cid] => 2148
    [pid] => 0
    [nid] => 1260
    [subject] => Re:Why can\'t humans digest cellulose?
    [comment] => 

I believe that humans could digest cellulose, if they're given the enzyme that digests cellulose. Maybe we need to modify the enzymes those bacteria make.

For instance people that suffer from diabetes, do not suffer now, without needing to insert genes into their genome ;)

[format] => 4 [timestamp] => 1220555475 [name] => John [mail] => [homepage] => [uid] => 490 [registered_name] => John [signature] => [signature_format] => 4 [picture] => [data] => a:14:{s:17:"profile_firstname";s:4:"John";s:16:"profile_lastname";s:8:"Kyrtatas";s:12:"profile_city";s:6:"Athens";s:16:"profile_address1";s:4:"NULL";s:16:"profile_address2";s:4:"NULL";s:7:"contact";i:0;s:13:"profile_title";s:0:"";s:19:"profile_affiliation";s:0:"";s:21:"profile_pro_interests";s:0:"";s:17:"profile_languages";s:0:"";s:16:"profile_comments";s:0:"";s:13:"form_build_id";s:37:"form-d3777b98c5def05b8ec60da0e34adebc";s:14:"picture_delete";s:0:"";s:14:"picture_upload";s:0:"";} [thread] => 01/ [status] => 0 [profile_firstname] => John [profile_lastname] => Kyrtatas [profile_city] => Athens [profile_address1] => NULL [profile_address2] => NULL [contact] => 0 [profile_title] => [profile_affiliation] => [profile_pro_interests] => [profile_languages] => [profile_comments] => [form_build_id] => form-d3777b98c5def05b8ec60da0e34adebc [picture_delete] => [picture_upload] => [depth] => 0 [new] => 0 )
Organophile, MEMBER
Vuxen, India
0 poäng (VäTE)


If a gene which causes the pancrease to secrete modified cellulases into the intestine is inserted into the genome than maybe we could obtain nutrition from cellulose.

Who knows, maybe the appensix could become useful again.

Does anyone know why man evolved from the ability to digest cellulose anyways?

 
   
stdClass Object
(
    [cid] => 2149
    [pid] => 0
    [nid] => 1260
    [subject] => Re:Why can\'t humans digest cellulose?
    [comment] => 

If a gene which causes the pancrease to secrete modified cellulases into the intestine is inserted into the genome than maybe we could obtain nutrition from cellulose.

Who knows, maybe the appensix could become useful again.

Does anyone know why man evolved from the ability to digest cellulose anyways?

[format] => 4 [timestamp] => 1220575758 [name] => Organophile [mail] => [homepage] => [uid] => 773 [registered_name] => Organophile [signature] => [signature_format] => 4 [picture] => [data] => a:13:{s:17:"profile_firstname";s:5:"Riyad";s:16:"profile_lastname";s:7:"Seervai";s:14:"profile_gender";s:3:"Boy";s:12:"profile_city";s:6:"Mumbai";s:16:"profile_address1";s:4:"NULL";s:16:"profile_address2";s:4:"NULL";s:7:"contact";s:1:"0";s:15:"profile_country";s:0:"";s:13:"profile_title";s:0:"";s:19:"profile_affiliation";s:0:"";s:21:"profile_pro_interests";s:0:"";s:17:"profile_languages";s:0:"";s:16:"profile_comments";s:0:"";} [thread] => 02/ [status] => 0 [profile_firstname] => Riyad [profile_lastname] => Seervai [profile_gender] => Boy [profile_city] => Mumbai [profile_address1] => NULL [profile_address2] => NULL [contact] => 0 [profile_country] => [profile_title] => [profile_affiliation] => [profile_pro_interests] => [profile_languages] => [profile_comments] => [depth] => 0 [new] => 0 )
inventorkid, MEMBER
16, United States
3 poäng (VäTE)


I don't think any animal can digest cellulose. Even termites have symbiotic protists in their digestive tracts to help them digest cellulose.

I think in theory there isn't any reason why humans couldn't digest cellulose if we were given the necessary gene. I don't think humans evolved away from that capability. I think it is just an ability animals never had.

 
   
stdClass Object
(
    [cid] => 2150
    [pid] => 0
    [nid] => 1260
    [subject] => Re:Why can\'t humans digest cellulose?
    [comment] => 

I don't think any animal can digest cellulose. Even termites have symbiotic protists in their digestive tracts to help them digest cellulose.

I think in theory there isn't any reason why humans couldn't digest cellulose if we were given the necessary gene. I don't think humans evolved away from that capability. I think it is just an ability animals never had.

[format] => 4 [timestamp] => 1220602407 [name] => inventorkid [mail] => [homepage] => [uid] => 438 [registered_name] => inventorkid [signature] => [signature_format] => 4 [picture] => [data] => a:13:{s:17:"profile_firstname";s:3:"Max";s:16:"profile_lastname";s:7:"Wallack";s:14:"profile_gender";s:3:"Boy";s:12:"profile_city";s:6:"Natick";s:16:"profile_address1";s:4:"NULL";s:16:"profile_address2";s:4:"NULL";s:7:"contact";s:1:"0";s:15:"profile_country";s:0:"";s:13:"profile_title";s:0:"";s:19:"profile_affiliation";s:0:"";s:21:"profile_pro_interests";s:0:"";s:17:"profile_languages";s:0:"";s:16:"profile_comments";s:0:"";} [thread] => 03/ [status] => 0 [profile_firstname] => Max [profile_lastname] => Wallack [profile_gender] => Boy [profile_city] => Natick [profile_address1] => NULL [profile_address2] => NULL [contact] => 0 [profile_country] => [profile_title] => [profile_affiliation] => [profile_pro_interests] => [profile_languages] => [profile_comments] => [depth] => 0 [new] => 0 )
inventorkid, MEMBER
16, United States
3 poäng (VäTE)


I don't think any animal can digest cellulose. Even termites have symbiotic protists in their digestive tracts to help them digest cellulose.

I think in theory there isn't any reason why humans couldn't digest cellulose if we were given the necessary gene. I don't think humans evolved away from that capability. I think it is just an ability animals never had.

 
   
stdClass Object
(
    [cid] => 2151
    [pid] => 0
    [nid] => 1260
    [subject] => Re:Why can\'t humans digest cellulose?
    [comment] => 

I don't think any animal can digest cellulose. Even termites have symbiotic protists in their digestive tracts to help them digest cellulose.

I think in theory there isn't any reason why humans couldn't digest cellulose if we were given the necessary gene. I don't think humans evolved away from that capability. I think it is just an ability animals never had.

[format] => 4 [timestamp] => 1220602427 [name] => inventorkid [mail] => [homepage] => [uid] => 438 [registered_name] => inventorkid [signature] => [signature_format] => 4 [picture] => [data] => a:13:{s:17:"profile_firstname";s:3:"Max";s:16:"profile_lastname";s:7:"Wallack";s:14:"profile_gender";s:3:"Boy";s:12:"profile_city";s:6:"Natick";s:16:"profile_address1";s:4:"NULL";s:16:"profile_address2";s:4:"NULL";s:7:"contact";s:1:"0";s:15:"profile_country";s:0:"";s:13:"profile_title";s:0:"";s:19:"profile_affiliation";s:0:"";s:21:"profile_pro_interests";s:0:"";s:17:"profile_languages";s:0:"";s:16:"profile_comments";s:0:"";} [thread] => 04/ [status] => 0 [profile_firstname] => Max [profile_lastname] => Wallack [profile_gender] => Boy [profile_city] => Natick [profile_address1] => NULL [profile_address2] => NULL [contact] => 0 [profile_country] => [profile_title] => [profile_affiliation] => [profile_pro_interests] => [profile_languages] => [profile_comments] => [depth] => 0 [new] => 0 )
berrywildgrl, MEMBER
2, United States
1 poäng (VäTE)


We need to spit it out and feed them and they will keep us alive.

 
   
stdClass Object
(
    [cid] => 2928
    [pid] => 0
    [nid] => 1260
    [subject] => We need to spit it out and
    [comment] => 

We need to spit it out and feed them and they will keep us alive.

[format] => 4 [timestamp] => 1264220863 [name] => berrywildgrl [mail] => [homepage] => [uid] => 1221 [registered_name] => berrywildgrl [signature] => [signature_format] => 4 [picture] => [data] => a:4:{s:13:"form_build_id";s:37:"form-27c55c0381df7e77d3262c43fd6cee4b";s:7:"captcha";s:0:"";s:11:"captcha_sid";s:4:"9419";s:16:"captcha_response";s:9:"reCAPTCHA";} [thread] => 05/ [status] => 0 [form_build_id] => form-27c55c0381df7e77d3262c43fd6cee4b [captcha] => [captcha_sid] => 9419 [captcha_response] => reCAPTCHA [depth] => 0 [new] => 0 )
steicy, MEMBER
Vuxen, Costa Rica
1 poäng (VäTE)


I believe that humans could digest cellulose, if they're given the enzyme that digests cellulose. Maybe we need to modify the enzymes those bacteria make.

 
   
stdClass Object
(
    [cid] => 3438
    [pid] => 0
    [nid] => 1260
    [subject] => I believe that humans could
    [comment] => 

I believe that humans could digest cellulose, if they're given the enzyme that digests cellulose. Maybe we need to modify the enzymes those bacteria make.

[format] => 4 [timestamp] => 1278665460 [name] => steicy [mail] => [homepage] => [uid] => 1334 [registered_name] => steicy [signature] => [signature_format] => 0 [picture] => [data] => a:4:{s:13:"form_build_id";s:37:"form-925d15343d4e752aeb591e57da4f22a4";s:7:"captcha";s:0:"";s:11:"captcha_sid";s:5:"24710";s:16:"captcha_response";s:9:"reCAPTCHA";} [thread] => 06/ [status] => 0 [form_build_id] => form-925d15343d4e752aeb591e57da4f22a4 [captcha] => [captcha_sid] => 24710 [captcha_response] => reCAPTCHA [depth] => 0 [new] => 0 )
orfeas, MEMBER
19, Greece
1668 poäng (SVAVEL)


I don't think that doing an injection every time we eat grass or modifying our DNA is a good idea... :)

 
   
stdClass Object
(
    [cid] => 3441
    [pid] => 0
    [nid] => 1260
    [subject] => I don't think that doing an
    [comment] => 

I don't think that doing an injection every time we eat grass or modifying our DNA is a good idea... :)

[format] => 4 [timestamp] => 1278861031 [name] => orfeas [mail] => [homepage] => [uid] => 1250 [registered_name] => orfeas [signature] => [signature_format] => 4 [picture] => sites/default/files/pictures/picture-1250.jpg [data] => a:6:{s:13:"form_build_id";s:37:"form-e867391558796ba6f1b37d185d4d1c28";s:7:"captcha";s:0:"";s:11:"captcha_sid";s:5:"16206";s:16:"captcha_response";s:9:"reCAPTCHA";s:14:"picture_delete";s:0:"";s:14:"picture_upload";s:0:"";} [thread] => 07/ [status] => 0 [form_build_id] => form-e867391558796ba6f1b37d185d4d1c28 [captcha] => [captcha_sid] => 16206 [captcha_response] => reCAPTCHA [picture_delete] => [picture_upload] => [depth] => 0 [new] => 0 )
zara454, MEMBER
Vuxen, United States
1 poäng (VäTE)


Cellulose acts as fibres which are good in digestion. So every one should include salads in their diet so that digestion is complete & good.

 
   
stdClass Object
(
    [cid] => 3460
    [pid] => 0
    [nid] => 1260
    [subject] => Cellulose acts as fibres
    [comment] => 

Cellulose acts as fibres which are good in digestion. So every one should include salads in their diet so that digestion is complete & good.

[format] => 4 [timestamp] => 1281961440 [name] => zara454 [mail] => [homepage] => [uid] => 1371 [registered_name] => zara454 [signature] => [signature_format] => 0 [picture] => [data] => a:4:{s:13:"form_build_id";s:37:"form-b6f201c5717b4b311099798ec323c6f4";s:7:"captcha";s:0:"";s:11:"captcha_sid";s:5:"40449";s:16:"captcha_response";s:9:"reCAPTCHA";} [thread] => 08/ [status] => 0 [form_build_id] => form-b6f201c5717b4b311099798ec323c6f4 [captcha] => [captcha_sid] => 40449 [captcha_response] => reCAPTCHA [depth] => 0 [new] => 0 )